An Unreleased Alternate Take of The Rolling Stones ‘Fool To Cry’ (1974)

By Marcelo Sonaglioni on May 16, 2025 • ( 2 Comments )

Like what you see? Help keep it going! This site runs on the support of readers like you. Your donation helps cover costs and keeps fresh Rolling Stones content coming your way every day. Thank you!

Rolling Stones unreleased: Fool to Cry (alternate take, 1974)

Written by: Jagger/Richard
Recorded: Musicland Studios, Munich, Germany, Dec. 5-19 1974
Guest musicians: Nicky Hopkins (piano and string synthesizer)
*Data taken from Martin Elliott’s book THE ROLLING STONES COMPLETE RECORDING SESSIONS 1962-2012

*Click for MORE STONES UNRELEASED TRACKS

rolling stones unreleased fool to cry alternate take 1974

Behind the Emotion: A Different Fool to Cry

Before it became the smooth, soulful ballad we know from Black and Blue, Fool to Cry existed in a rawer, more vulnerable form. This alternate take, recorded during sessions at Musicland Studios in Munich between December 5 and 19, 1974, offers a stripped-down glimpse into the emotional heart of the song. The version reveals the Rolling Stones at their most introspective—less polished, more exposed. With Nicky Hopkins contributing his signature piano flourishes and adding depth with string synthesizer textures, the track pulses with sincerity and ache. Mick Jagger’s vocals aren’t yet shaped by studio gloss; instead, they waver with honesty, capturing the loneliness and heartbreak that inspired the song. This take feels like an intimate conversation—less performance, more confession. It’s a sonic snapshot of a moment when the band was redefining their sound after the Taylor era, embracing new moods while still rooted in emotional storytelling.

A Glimpse Inside the Studio

The 1974 sessions at Musicland Studios weren’t just about experimentation—they were a bridge between eras. With Mick Taylor gone and Ronnie Wood not yet a full member, the Stones were searching for a new direction. This version of Fool to Cry reflects that transitional energy. The presence of guest musician Nicky Hopkins, a frequent collaborator and unsung hero in the Stones’ catalog, brings warmth and subtle complexity. His piano work anchors the melody, while the string synth lines hint at the atmospheric direction the band would later explore more fully. Though ultimately unreleased at the time, this alternate take stands as a fascinating artifact of a band in flux—revealing the human fragility behind the swagger, and the quiet beauty behind the hits.

COPYRIGHT © ROLLING STONES DATA
ALL INFORMATION ON THIS WEBSITE IS COPYRIGHT OF ROLLING STONES DATA. ALL CONTENT BY MARCELO SONAGLIONI.
ALL SETLISTS AND TICKET STUBS TAKEN FROM THE COMPLETE WORKS OF THE ROLLING STONES.
WHEN USING INFORMATION FROM ROLLING STONES DATA (ONLINE OR PRINTED) PLEASE REFER TO ITS SOURCE DETAILING THE WEBSITE NAME. THANK YOU.