Like what you see? Help keep it going! This site runs on the support of readers like you. Your donation helps cover costs and keeps fresh Rolling Stones content updated every day. Thanks in advance!

About The Rolling Stones’ Lost Compilation The Black Box

*Click for MORE STONES ARTICLES

*By Marcelo Sonaglioni

Before deluxe reissues became rock’s favorite cash machine, The Rolling Stones were already sitting on a mountain of forgotten chaos. In 1974, bassist Bill Wyman tried turning that hidden archive into The Black Box, a mysterious unreleased project that could have reshaped how fans viewed the band’s creative leftovers. Instead, history took a different turn, and collectors were left chasing rumors, bootlegs, and half-whispered track lists like detectives in flared pants. Somewhere between artistic perfectionism and typical Stones disorder, songs tied to albums like Metamorphosis became part myth, part buried treasure.

In February 1974 Bill Wyman quietly began piecing together what could have become one of the most fascinating archival releases in The Rolling Stones history. Only that it didn’t happen. Working with tapes stored and reviewed through the band’s famous mobile facility, the Rolling Stones Mobile Studio, the Stones’ bassist started compiling a collection of unreleased studio recordings under the working title The Black Box. At a time when the Stones were transitioning into a new era after years of relentless touring, shifting musical styles, and internal tension, the project offered a rare chance to dig deep into the vault and revisit abandoned songs, alternate versions, unfinished ideas, and forgotten sessions stretching across the band’s most creative years.

Unlike standard “greatest hits” compilations, The Black Box was envisioned as something far more mysterious and collector-oriented: a behind-the-scenes snapshot of the Stones’ creative process. Wyman, known within the band as the member most interested in archiving and preserving their history, reportedly selected tracks that highlighted obscure corners of their catalog rather than obvious crowd-pleasers. The idea reflected growing fan fascination with bootlegs and unreleased material during the early 1970s, when collectors were becoming increasingly aware that the Stones’ vault contained dozens of unheard recordings.

The forgotten Rolling Stones vault project

The project generated serious internal discussion, and preliminary work reportedly moved forward during early 1974. However, as the band focused on new material and other business matters, enthusiasm for the compilation gradually faded. The concept was ultimately abandoned before completion, leaving The Black Box as one of the great “lost albums” in Rolling Stones lore. Some of the material that may have been considered for the set would later circulate unofficially among collectors, adding to the project’s almost mythical reputation.

Instead of releasing Wyman’s carefully curated archival package, the Stones’ camp eventually issued Metamorphosis in 1975. That release leaned more heavily on demos, alternate takes, outtakes, and recordings connected to the band’s complicated relationship with former manager Allen Klein and ABKCO. While Metamorphosis remains an intriguing release in its own right, many fans and historians have long wondered how different — and perhaps more cohesive — Wyman’s original The Black Box concept might have been. Bill Wyman’s original selections for the planned album reportedly included:

June 1975
Rolling Stones – The Black Box, as originally compiled By Bill Wyman (Decca acetate)

SIDE A
Bright Lights, Big City (Jimmy Reed)
Cops And Robbers (Kent Harris)
I’d Much Rather Be With The Boys (Oldham/Richards)
Little Red Rooster (Willie Dixon)
Down The Road Apiece (Don Raye)
Don’t Lie To Me (Hudson Whittaker) *wrongly entitled Let’s Talk It Over

SIDE B
If You Let Me (Jagger/Richard)
Godzi (instrumental, by Nanker, Phelge)
Panama Powder Room ((instrumental, by Jagger/Richard)
Gold Painted Nails (Jagger/Richard)
Fanny Mae (Bobby Robinson, Clarence Lewis, Buster Brown)
Down In The Bottom (Willie Dixon)

A1: Recorded at IBC Studios, London, March 11, 1963
A2: Recorded at Camden Theatre, London, March 19, 1964
A3: Recorded at Demo session, Decca Studios, London, late February, 1965
A4, A5: Recorded on the British tour, March 5-18, 1965
A6: Recorded at Chess Studios, Chicago, June 10 or 11, 1964
B1: Recorded at Olympic Sound Studios, London, November 9-26, 1966
B2, B3: Recorded at RCA Studios, Hollywood, August 4-12, 1966
B4: Recorded at Olympic Sound Studios, London, October 16, 21 or 23, 1967
B5: Recorded at “Saturday Club”, BBC radio show, August 20, 1965
B6: Recorded at Chess Studios, Chicago, June 11, 1964

COPYRIGHT © ROLLING STONES DATA
ALL INFORMATION ON THIS WEBSITE IS COPYRIGHT OF ROLLING STONES DATA. ALL CONTENT BY MARCELO SONAGLIONI.
ALL SETLISTS AND TICKET STUBS TAKEN FROM THE COMPLETE WORKS OF THE ROLLING STONES. 
WHEN USING INFORMATION FROM ROLLING STONES DATA (ONLINE OR PRINTED) PLEASE REFER TO ITS SOURCE DETAILING THE WEBSITE NAME. THANK YOU.